Walmart vs Amazon: The Comparison Showdown for Sellers
In the world of e-commerce, Amazon and Walmart reign supreme, dominating the retail landscape. These two giants offer vast opportunities for third-party sellers looking to expand their business. But with such similar offerings, how do you decide which platform is the right fit for you?
In this blog, we’ll dive deep into the world of Walmart vs. Amazon, comparing them on key factors like fulfillment, costs, branding, and international opportunities. Whether you’re a seasoned seller or just starting out, this comparison will help you make an informed decision about where to sell your products online.
Overview of Amazon vs. Walmart
Amazon and Walmart are two of the largest e-commerce marketplaces in the US, commanding a combined market share of over 70%. Amazon leads the pack with a market share of around 40%, while Walmart follows as the second-largest, holding approximately 10%. Each platform has its unique strengths and weaknesses, and understanding these differences is crucial for sellers aiming to make informed decisions about where to list their products.
Amazon is renowned for its vast customer base, boasting over 300 million active customers worldwide. The platform offers a plethora of tools and services to help sellers manage their businesses effectively. Amazon’s Seller Central is a comprehensive dashboard that provides detailed sales data and analytics, empowering sellers with insights to optimize their strategies. Additionally, Amazon offers various fulfillment options, including the popular Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service, which allows sellers to store their products in Amazon’s warehouses and have them shipped directly to customers.
On the other hand, Walmart is celebrated for its everyday low prices and its formidable presence in the retail industry. With over 140 million customers visiting its stores weekly, Walmart has a substantial and loyal customer base. The Walmart Marketplace is rapidly expanding, currently featuring over 150,000 sellers. Walmart provides a range of tools and services to assist sellers, including Walmart’s Seller Center, which offers detailed sales data and analytics similar to Amazon’s Seller Central.
Let’s compare both platforms on some of the most important parameters for sellers planning to sell online.
1. Seller Requirements
Amazon
Amazon requires a professional seller account, which comes with a monthly fee of $39.99. While there is an individual seller plan with no monthly fee, it has limitations on the number of products you can list and other features.
Amazon places high importance on seller performance. You must maintain a low late shipment rate and a high valid tracking rate. Failure to meet these standards can result in penalties or account suspension. Managing metrics such as credit card chargebacks is also crucial for maintaining account health and preventing account suspension due to customer dissatisfaction. Here are a few other details that you’ll need to setup a store on Amazon.
Business name
Bank account number where Amazon can send sales proceeds
Address
Phone Number
Contact information
Internationally chargeable credit card
Tax identify information
Walmart Marketplace
US Business tax ID or business license number (SSN isn’t accepted)
US business address
Address of physical operations
W9 or W8 and EIN Verification Letter from the Department of Treasury
Walmart has a more stringent vetting process for new sellers. You may need to provide proof of your supply chain and operational capability before being approved. This rigorous vetting process ensures seller stability, which is crucial for maintaining a reliable selling environment with clear and consistent policy enforcement.
No monthly subscription fees, but sellers pay additional fees based on sales.
Sellers must maintain high order accuracy potential and order defect rate.
2. Platform Costs and Monthly Subscription Fees
Amazon
Professional Seller Account: $39.99 monthly fee
Referral Fees: Typically range from 8% to 15% of the item’s sale price.
Closing Fees: $1.80 for media products.
Refund Processing Fees: $5.00 or 20% of the item’s price.
Weight-Based Returns Fee: Varies based on the weight of the returned item.
Storage Fees:
83 cents per cubic foot monthly storage.
$6.90 per cubic foot for long-term storage.
Fulfillment Fees: Depend on the item’s size, weight, and shipping method.
Walmart
No Monthly Seller Fees
Referral Fees: Typically range from 8% to 15% of the item’s sale price.
Storage Fees:
75 cents per cubic foot monthly storage.
$1.50 per cubic foot extra fee for items stored beyond 30 days.
$7.50 per cubic foot for long-term storage.
Fulfillment Fees: Vary per item size and weight.
In general, Walmart’s Marketplace tends to have lower selling costs, but Amazon makes up for its higher fees by providing more tools for shoppers and sellers alike.
3. Fulfillment and Shipping Options
Fulfillment and shipping are crucial aspects of e-commerce, and both Amazon and Walmart offer various options to help sellers manage these processes efficiently.
Amazon FBA
Amazon’s FBA program is a popular choice for sellers. It offers a comprehensive solution, taking care of storage, picking, packing, shipping, and customer service. Sellers send their products to Amazon fulfillment centers, and Amazon handles the rest. This can be especially beneficial for sellers who want to focus on product sourcing and marketing.
Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS)
Walmart’s WFS is a newer service that offers similar benefits to FBA. Sellers can send their products to Walmart fulfillment centers, and Walmart will handle storage, picking, packing, and shipping. WFS is still expanding, but it has the potential to become a strong competitor to FBA.
Both platforms offer fulfillment services, but Amazon vs Walmart differs in their approach to shipping, fees, and storage.
Self-Fulfillment
For sellers who prefer to handle fulfillment themselves, both Amazon and Walmart offer self-fulfillment options. This means that sellers are responsible for storing, packing, and shipping their products. While self-fulfillment can provide more control over the process, it also requires more time and resources.
4. Onboarding Process and Seller Tools
Amazon
Amazon’s onboarding process is straightforward, and its Seller Central dashboard offers a wide range of tools for managing sales, listings, and advertising. Amazon’s Seller Central provides a comprehensive dashboard that allows sellers to control pricing, manage listings, and access various analytics tools. Additionally, Amazon supports bulk product uploads, making it ideal for sellers with large inventories.
Walmart
Walmart’s Marketplace onboarding is more selective, focusing on larger, well-established brands. While the platform provides various seller tools to optimize sales, they are not as robust as Amazon’s system.
5. Pricing and Buy Box Competition
Pricing and Buy Box competition are pivotal factors for sellers on both Amazon and Walmart. The Buy Box, prominently displayed on the right-hand side of the product detail page, contains the “Add to Cart” button and is a critical driver of sales and visibility. Winning the Buy Box can significantly boost a seller’s sales, making it a coveted spot.
Amazon’s pricing algorithm is intricate, considering various factors such as the seller’s price, shipping cost, and customer reviews. To stay competitive, sellers must vigilantly monitor their prices and adjust them regularly. Amazon provides several pricing tools, including the Amazon Pricing Dashboard, which offers detailed pricing data and analytics to help sellers make informed decisions.
Similarly, Walmart’s pricing algorithm is complex, taking into account factors like the seller’s price, shipping cost, and customer reviews. Walmart also offers a range of pricing tools, including the Walmart Pricing Dashboard, which provides comprehensive pricing data and analytics. However, Walmart’s pricing rules are more stringent than Amazon’s, requiring sellers to be cautious to avoid violations.
6. Advertising
Amazon's Advertising Platform
Amazon’s advertising platform is vast and comprehensive, offering a variety of options for sellers. At the core of Amazon’s advertising is Sponsored Products, which allows sellers to bid on keywords relevant to their products and appear in search results. Amazon also offers Sponsored Brands for brand awareness, Sponsored Display for retargeting customers, and Product Display Ads for showcasing complementary products. Amazon’s advertising platform is highly integrated with its search engine, making it easier for sellers to target relevant customers.
Walmart's Advertising Platform
Walmart’s advertising capabilities are growing, but they are still somewhat limited compared to Amazon. Walmart offers Sponsored Products, similar to Amazon, allowing sellers to bid on keywords and appear in search results. However, Walmart’s advertising platform is less mature and doesn’t offer the same breadth of options as Amazon.
7. International Sellers
Both Amazon and Walmart have become attractive platforms for non-US sellers aiming to access the American market. On Amazon, international sellers make up a substantial 52% of top third-party merchants. Walmart, too, has seen a surge in foreign sellers, with 43% of its new sellers coming from outside the US—primarily from China in both cases.
To sell on Amazon, non-US residents need to fulfill specific legal requirements like US taxpayer status, a supported country bank account, and often incorporation within the US. Many choose to set up a local US entity to simplify banking and compliance.
Walmart allows incorporation either in the US or in one of the 14 eligible countries, and while a US taxpayer ID isn’t required, you do need a US phone number and a return address. You can also use the W-8BEN-E tax form for taxation purposes.
For US-based sellers wanting to go international, Amazon Global allows shipping to over 100 countries, or sellers can create stores on Amazon’s various international marketplaces. Walmart, on the other hand, is limited to US shipments only and does not offer any international shipping options.
8. Customer Support and Performance Standards
Amazon
Amazon’s performance standards include maintaining low order defects and late shipment rates. Failing to meet these can lead to account suspension. Managing metrics such as credit card chargebacks is also crucial for maintaining account health and preventing account suspension due to customer dissatisfaction.
Amazon customers tend to expect faster delivery times, especially Prime members, which puts additional pressure on sellers.
Walmart
Walmart customers are often more price-sensitive, and Walmart holds its sellers to high standards, focusing on order accuracy and a smooth e-commerce experience.
Performance standards on Walmart are stringent but often more manageable for new sellers compared to Amazon. Marketplace sellers must meet specific performance metrics and customer service standards to maintain their accounts and ensure customer satisfaction.
9. Pros and Cons of Selling on Amazon vs. Walmart
Amazon
Pros:
Amazon reigns supreme in the e-commerce world with a vast consumer base.
Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) makes shipping and storage a breeze.
Access to Prime members, who are known for their higher spending habits.
Diverse product categories, from groceries to general merchandise.
Cons:
High seller fees, including referral fees and fulfillment fees.
Intense competition from many sellers.
Risk of account suspension for even minor infractions.
High order defect rate can lead to negative feedback and seller instability.
Unauthorized sellers may violate MAP by advertising products at a lower price, and Amazon’s price-matching policy can automatically lower your price if a competitor lists a lower price, creating a challenging pricing environment.
Walmart
Pros:
Walmart Marketplace is rapidly growing with less competition compared to Amazon.
Lower monthly subscription fees for sellers.
Access to Walmart customers, many of whom are loyal to the brand’s low-cost reputation.
Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS) offers a cost-efficient solution for shipping and storage.
Cons:
Unlike Amazon, Walmart lacks the international reach.
Seller account setup can be slower and more complicated.
Limited customer support tools compared to Amazon’s Seller Central.
Conclusion
When comparing Walmart and Amazon, each platform has its advantages and challenges. Amazon boasts a vast marketplace with global reach and advanced seller tools, but it comes with fierce competition and higher fees. In contrast, Walmart offers a growing platform with less competition and lower fees, though its international presence is more limited, and the onboarding process can be more complex. Both platforms aim to provide products at competitive prices.
For sellers aiming to stay competitive in the retail landscape, understanding the intricacies of both platforms is crucial. Whether you prioritize cost-efficiency, fulfillment options, or global reach, choosing between Amazon and Walmart’s marketplace ultimately depends on your business goals.
In today’s competitive retail landscape, reaching the right audience at the right time is crucial for success. Walmart’s Demand Side […]
In today’s fast-paced eCommerce landscape, shoppers demand speedy delivery. Walmart has responded by offering 2-day shipping, giving sellers on the […]
Running successful Walmart advertising campaigns takes more than just setting them up—it requires ongoing optimization. A Walmart PPC (Pay-Per-Click) audit […]
Are you ready to tap into the massive potential of Walmart Marketplace? With millions of daily visitors and a loyal […]
In the world of e-commerce, Amazon and Walmart reign supreme, dominating the retail landscape. These two giants offer vast opportunities […]
Are you a brand owner struggling to maintain control over your products on Walmart? The Walmart Brand Portal is here […]
Are you dreaming of a passive income stream from your Walmart store? The allure of an automated Walmart store with […]
Are you a seller looking to tap into the massive market of private-label brands? Walmart, one of the world’s largest […]
Tired of your Walmart products getting lost in the shuffle? In this blog post, we’ll dive into the essential strategies […]
Ever wondered why some Amazon sellers seem to have a magic touch with product bundles? It’s not luck—it’s strategy. Bundling […]
If you’re a Walmart seller looking to grow your business through retail media, Walmart Connect could be a game-changer. But […]
If you’re an Amazon seller, you may have noticed a portion of your inventory marked as “reserved” without knowing exactly […]
Have you ever wondered what managing your own Amazon orders is like? Switching from Fulfilled by Amazon (FBA) to Fulfilled […]
Walmart Marketplace offers an exciting opportunity for sellers to reach a vast audience by listing their products on Walmart’s platform. […]
Selling products on online marketplaces has become a vital strategy for businesses to reach more customers. If you’re looking to […]
Are you a Walmart seller aiming to improve your visibility and sales? In this blog, we will explore Walmart SEO, […]
As an Amazon brand owner, maintaining control over your product listings is essential to protect your brand’s reputation and customer […]
Introduction Tired of losing out on Walmart sales to competitors? Want to know the secret to consistently winning the Buy […]
Are you an Amazon seller wondering what the IPI score is and how it affects your business? Look no further! […]
Introduction Starting an Amazon subscription box business presents a unique opportunity to tap into the growing trend of curated, recurring […]
Thinking about using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) to sell on the Amazon marketplace? Awesome! But before you box up your […]
Thinking about using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) to streamline your Amazon business? While FBA offers a convenient way to store […]
For FBA sellers, the Amazon Buy Box is the holy grail of product visibility. But with constant algorithm updates and […]
Have you ever wished you could offer customers pre-made packages of complementary products without the hassle of physically bundling them […]
Have you ever wanted to create a more branded and engaging presence for your products on Amazon? An Amazon storefront […]
When selling products on Amazon, it is crucial to follow their packaging requirements, rules, and guidelines. Proper packaging ensures that […]
A/B testing on Amazon can significantly enhance your product listings and boost sales. This method, also known as split testing, […]
Have you ever browsed Amazon and stumbled upon a product with a little blue badge that reads “Amazon’s Choice”? It […]
Introduction Selling on Amazon can be a great way to get your products out there. But once someone buys your […]
Ever feel like you’re missing something in your Amazon PPC Search Terms report? You might be! Sure, they show what […]
Amazon can be a fantastic platform to reach new customers, but keeping your virtual shelves stocked can get tricky. That’s […]
Navigating Amazon as a new seller can be tough, but there are tools and programs available to help. Amazon’s Launchpad […]
Have you ever scrolled through an Amazon search result page and noticed product recommendations nestled alongside the standard listings? These […]
Finding time for yourself while selling on a competitive marketplace like Amazon can be challenging. As a seller, your main […]
Starting an E-commerce business has become quite easy with Amazon, but it also brings heavy competition. Millions of Amazon sellers […]
As an Amazon seller, you know the importance of getting your products seen. But with millions of listings, how do […]
Ever scrutinized an Amazon product page and noticed the cryptic “Sales Rank”? Wondering what it means and how it impacts […]
Millions of products compete for customer attention on Amazon’s search results page, making it tough for your brand to stand […]
Are you selling products on Amazon and looking to increase your sales? This blog is for you. We’ll share tips […]
Are you an Amazon seller looking to boost your brand visibility and profitability? Are you feeling stuck in the cycle […]
Ever wonder what drives your online shopping habits? Perhaps a captivating product description, or an eye-catching professional photo? As it […]
For any seller on Amazon, understanding the A9 algorithm is crucial for success. This complex algorithm dictates which products appear […]
Are you an Amazon seller looking to turn those single purchases into recurring revenue? Look no further than the Subscribe […]
Amazon has become a go-to platform for all e-commerce business owners to launch and scale their e-commerce brands online. But […]
Mother’s Day, a time to celebrate the incredible women who raised us, is a prime opportunity for Amazon sellers to […]
In the ever-competitive landscape of Amazon, ranking high in organic search results is crucial for driving sales. While you might […]
If you’ve ever found yourself scratching your head over Sessions and Pageviews on your Amazon business reports, you’re not alone. At […]
Amazon is a massive marketplace, attracting millions of customers with diverse needs, preferences, budgets, and mindsets for shopping. To effectively […]
With Amazon boasting over $575 billion in retail sales for 2023, it’s no wonder so many sellers flock to its […]
Advertising on Amazon through pay-per-click campaigns can significantly enhance product visibility and sales for sellers. However, mastering Amazon PPC, with […]
Have you heard of the terms copyright infringement and plagiarism? If so, then Amazon Brand gating won’t be unfamiliar to […]
If you are running ads on Amazon, you’ll come across a sea of data in your advertising console. But does […]
Have you heard of the terms copyright infringement and plagiarism? If so, then Amazon Brand gating won’t be unfamiliar to […]
In the fast-paced world of e-commerce, where shoppers are bombarded with choices, standing out on platforms like Amazon is paramount […]
Are you planning to start an Amazon FBA store? If so, you’ll encounter a unique term – FNSKU. This seemingly […]
Introduction As an Amazon seller, you understand the power of reviews. They’re the lifeblood of trust and conversion on the […]
Are you struggling to get Amazon reviews on your product? Well, you are not alone! Reviews are the backbone of […]
Are you tired of bland Amazon product listings failing to grab attention? In today’s competitive online marketplace, standing out is […]
As an Amazon seller, understanding how your brand performs throughout the customer journey is vital for success. However, until recently, […]
As an Amazon seller, optimizing your business and maximizing profits relies heavily on data analysis. One invaluable tool for gaining […]
Are you struggling to get noticed on Amazon’s massive platform? Do your products get lost in a sea of similar […]
For any Amazon seller getting into the world of sponsored advertising, understanding the Advertising Cost of Sale (ACoS) is crucial. […]
A well-executed product launch on Amazon can be the key to unlocking success and gaining a competitive edge. As the […]
In the ever-evolving landscape of e-commerce, distinguishing between keywords and search terms is vital for optimizing product visibility and driving […]
Ever felt like you are throwing darts in the dark when it comes to your marketing efforts outside Amazon for […]
Amazon, the e-commerce giant, has successfully concluded a robust business year with outstanding performance in quarter 4. The most recent […]
Picture this: you have a great product on Amazon, but it’s not selling well despite having attractive images and a […]
The advertising landscape is evolving, and viewers are rapidly migrating from traditional cable TV to streaming platforms. This presents a […]
Feeling lost in the Amazon discount jungle? Struggling to reach the right customers and entice them to make the purchase? […]
Are you losing your product in the deep ocean of Amazon product listings? Want your product to stand out, rank […]
For years, Amazon sellers were in the dark. They couldn’t see what keywords customers were using to find their products, […]
Selling on Amazon can be tough with so many others doing the same in your category. That’s why it’s super […]
For Amazon sellers, understanding their customers has often felt like navigating a maze without a map. The missing link? A […]
Have you ever felt like your Amazon advertising campaigns are lost in a tangled jungle of keywords? You’re not alone. […]
When did you last give your Amazon PPC account a checkup? Regular Amazon PPC audits are crucial to ensure the […]
Embarking on the path of online selling? If so, you’re likely aware that Amazon is your ultimate destination. With a […]
Ever felt like your product is lost in the vast Amazon jungle? You’re not alone. With millions of shoppers actively […]
Amazon Sellers selling on the Amazon marketplace usually utilize Amazon advertising without keeping a close eye on the TACoS metric. […]
The rush of Black Friday and Cyber Monday might be over, but the opportunity for continued sales growth extends beyond […]
In the fierce Amazon advertising domain, where competition rises and costs increase, understanding and keeping track of the right metrics […]
Have you ever felt the frustration of campaigns going out of budget, leading to missing out on potential sales, or, […]
Amazon PPC campaigns can be a powerful tool for driving traffic and sales to your products. However, without proper structure, they […]
The Amazon Cyber Monday and Black Friday sales week is just around the corner. It’s no secret that this marks […]
Whether you are creating a new advertising campaign or optimizing existing ones, doing it manually from the Amazon ad console […]
Want to know what search terms people use to visit or purchase your product on Amazon? If yes, you’re in […]
When you are spending dollars or even more to get a click on your Amazon ads, you want to ensure […]
Are you an Amazon seller looking to maximize your profits and minimize your advertising costs? If so, you’re not alone. Many […]
Are you exclusively relying on traditional metrics such as CTR, CPC, CVR, or ROAS to make your campaign optimization decisions? […]
Navigating the ever-evolving landscape of Amazon’s online marketplace is essential for any seller looking to thrive on the platform. Among […]
As the holiday season approaches, businesses are gearing up for the highly anticipated Q4 rush. To ensure a successful Q4, […]
Do you regularly review your Amazon advertising reports? If not, you may be missing out on numerous opportunities. Amazon […]
Whether you’ve just launched a new product or have been selling on Amazon for a while, advertising on the platform […]
Amazon PPC bidding strategies that you choose play a significant role in the success of your Amazon Ads campaigns. As […]
Have you ever heard of a “catch-all campaign”? This single campaign can generate extra sales for you at a very […]
Amazon Prime Day is one of the largest global e-commerce sales events, attracting millions of customers worldwide. But how do […]
Are you looking to boost your brand’s visibility and drive more sales on Amazon? Look no further than Amazon Sponsored […]
Succeeding on Amazon in 2023 isn’t easy. Just listing your products and hoping for the best won’t work anymore. You […]
Are you bidding the same amount for all your ad placements on Amazon? If yes, then you’re missing out on […]
Whether you are looking to boost product discovery or target audiences further down the sales funnel who have already engaged […]
We, at Adbrew catalyze millions of dollars of ad spend monthly through our platform, with Sponsored Product Ads being the […]
Do you want to know how many clicks you should give a search term before adding it as negative in […]
Think of your product listing as a guiding light on the Amazon marketplace. It’s your chance to grab attention, tell […]
It is no longer a secret that shopping behavior on Amazon varies over the day. This is the reason why […]
Are you struggling to get the most out of your advertising budget on Amazon? Do you find that your campaigns […]
Ever run an Amazon Ad campaign and wondered why some sales weren’t directly linked to the products you advertised? That’s […]
If you’re managing Amazon PPC ads, it’s essential to have an effective and organized approach for target harvesting and movement. […]